Another 30-year wait on Cross Harbor Freight Tunnel?

TimesLedger Newspapers
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Get our stories in your inbox, free.

Like TimesLedger on Facebook.

Governor Andrew Cuomo’s announcement that the Port Authority of New York & New Jersey will spend up to $70 million on advancing an environmental study, as well as design and engineering for the Cross Harbor Freight Tunnel, still leaves a $9.930 billion shortfall to complete this project.

Last year, Manhattan-Brooklyn Congressman Jerrold Nadler (D-10th District) claimed that there is real progress for his favorite Cross Harbor Freight Tunnel project. This doesn’t add up if you look at past history.

This project has been championed by Nadler as his No. 1 transportation priority for almost 30 years. After all that time, it has yet to progress beyond the federal NEPA environmental review process.

In theory, it might move thousands of trucks on a daily basis off the roads and on to railroad tracks for significant portions of the journey between New Jersey and Long Island. It reminds me of the long-forgotten proposed tunnel between 69th Street in Bay Ridge and St. George. The concept was to extend subway service from Brooklyn to Staten Island. Ground was broken with entrances at both ends in the 1920’s, but the project quickly ran out of money and was abandoned to history.

When living on Shore Road in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, friends and I would look to no avail in attempting to find the abandoned site filled in decades earlier. Flash forward 90 years later and we have the proposed “Cross Harbor” rail freight tunnel project.

Construction of any new freight, public transportation tunnel or bridge project can take years, if not decades, by the time all feasibility studies, environmental reviews, planning, design, engineering, real estate acquisition, permits, procurements, construction, budgeting, identifying and securing funding is completed. This is before the project reaches beneficial use.

Construction for the 2nd Avenue subway began in the 1960’s (bond money intended for this project in the 1950’s was spent elsewhere). The first segment of three stations between 63rd and 96th Streets on the upper east side of Manhattan was finally opened to the public on Jan. 1, 2017, at a cost of $4.5 billion. Construction for the original tunnel to support bringing the Long Island Rail Road from Queens into Grand Central Terminal began in the 1960’s. The latest completion date is now December 2023 with a cost of $10.8 billion. No one can identify all the sources for the estimated $24 billion to build a new tunnel for New Jersey Transit, and Amtrak known as the “Gateway project,” to gain additional access to Penn Station from New Jersey. Ditto for paying back the $3 billion federal loan which covered a majority of the estimated $4 billion for replacing the Tappan Zee Bridge in Westchester.

Any guess who will find $10 billion or more needed for construction of a new Cross Harbor Freight Tunnel? The Port Authority of NY & NJ, Congressmember Nadler nor Governor Cuomo have yet to identify and secure the billions neeed to fund final design and engineering, let alone construction.

The PANYNJ also needs to find $1.8 billion for PATH extension from Newark, New Jersey to Newark Airport, $7 billion toward the $10 billion total cost for a new Port Authority Bus Terminal in midtown Manhattan, along with billions more for other transportation investments.

There is also a potential serious conflict with the proposed $1 to $2 billion Triboro X — a new subway connecting the Bronx with Queens and Brooklyn. The route would run parallel from Cross Harbor Freight Tunnel Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, terminus on to Queens. This would result in serious operational conflicts between freight and subway trains.

The proposed Cross Harbor Freight Tunnel may be just another in the continuing series of feasibility studies and environmental reviews sponsored by various governmental agencies and public officials over decades. They generate some money for consultants, along with free publicity for elected officials who promise a bright future, but all to often move on to another public office before delivering. Taxpayers are frequently left holding an empty bag with unfilled promises. Some NYC residents who oppose the project based on concerns about significant future increases in the number, length and frequency of freight trains need not worry. At the end of the day, just like the long-abandoned Brooklyn to Staten Island subway project - don’t count on seeing any shovel in the ground any time soon.

It is wishful thinking that the PA NY & NJ can count on billions in future federal funding to make up the difference. Don’t be surprised in waiting another 30 years until future PA NY&NJ ten-year capital plans are approved before a complete $10 billion (or more) funding package is in place. These are necessary to support awarding construction contracts.

Project supporters who are looking for completion of a new Cross Harbor Freight Tunnel may not live long enough to see this in their lifetime.

Larry Penner is a transportation historian and advocate who previously worked 31 years for the U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Transit Administration Region 2 NY Office

Posted 12:00 am, May 18, 2017
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Get our stories in your inbox, free.

Like TimesLedger on Facebook.

Reader feedback

jim doig from north of Queens (Hanover NH) says:
A good article, I think, except that you seem to think the tunnel would be accepted (and partly paid for) by the RRs, and that containerization would be possible on the Brooklyn side (very unlikely in view of the current uses in western Brooklyn). Is there really anything but a waste of planning $$ here? — Jim Doig (author of Empire on the Hudson)
May 18, 2017, 9:31 am
Pj from Queens says:
The city can never do anything right to begin with. This whole city and long island is in desperate need of traffic relief but the government just wants to keep adding more and more people into this city which certainly doesn't help truckers going from nj to long island. The nyc government needs to stop taking in so many people and yes, there is a way for this,to be done because ive heard of european countries that do it or ATLEAST perhaps limit people to how many cars they can own in this city. Does the government not realize that all of nyc and long island is a safety hazard? If this whole island needed to evacuate for some catastrophic reason, then 3/4 of us would not make it out alive. PERHAPS maybe the city and long island should start issuing housing tickets. If you dont have a housing ticket,you cant live,here but then again our government cant even enforce illegal immigration laws so I guess its just wishful dreaming on my end!
May 18, 2017, 10:27 am
Joe from Maspeth says:
Maybe some of you should read the NY Daily News Editorial from May 11, 2017. Which makes a persuasive case for the Cross Harbor rail freight tunnel. The editorial can be summed up in six words: "Find the money. Then get digging."

Of light and tunnels: Cuomo’s smart push for harbor freight rail tube
May 18, 2017, 10:42 am
Pedro Valdez Rivera Jr. says:
I am certain agree Larry: Transportation studies makes the elected officials get 15 minutes of fame while the rest of us taxpayers will get the lump of coal, all thanks to broken promises there.
May 20, 2017, 8:53 am

Enter your comment below

By submitting this comment, you agree to the following terms:

You agree that you, and not or its affiliates, are fully responsible for the content that you post. You agree not to post any abusive, obscene, vulgar, slanderous, hateful, threatening or sexually-oriented material or any material that may violate applicable law; doing so may lead to the removal of your post and to your being permanently banned from posting to the site. You grant to the royalty-free, irrevocable, perpetual and fully sublicensable license to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, publish, translate, create derivative works from, distribute, perform and display such content in whole or in part world-wide and to incorporate it in other works in any form, media or technology now known or later developed.

MetroPlus NY Cancer and Blood Specialists NYU Winthrop VillageCareMax


Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: